How to Recruit Mentors and Mentees to Your Mentoring Program

1 minutes

You know the old saying: Participants make a mentoring program.

You could have the best designed and structured mentoring program going, but if mentors and mentees are not keen to get involved, it’s not going to be successful.

Recruiting mentors and mentees can be challenging, so we’ve compiled a number of suggestions from what we’ve seen working at Guider.

Firstly, it’s important to bear in mind there are a number of different uses of mentoring, and depending on the purpose and objective of your program, the way you recruit mentors and mentees will differ.

For example, getting sign ups for a graduate career development program will be different to one aimed at those returning after parental leave. This should be factored into your planning stages to make sure you allow enough time for promotion and recruitment prior to program launch.

Here are our suggestions on how to recruit mentors and mentees to your mentoring program:

1. Get leadership buy-in

One of the most crucial factors in the success of any mentoring program is leadership buy-in. Having the senior leadership team advocating for the importance of mentoring will have huge impact in how the program is received throughout the business. Those who hold authority, on both a seniority and a personal level, have the power to influence sentiment within the workforce, and so it’s important to get them on side.

Megan Taljaard, L&D Manager at NTT Data UK, reiterated this learning on a recent webinar after their CEO became a mentoring champion:

“Buy in from the senior leadership team is really important, because they’re the ones cascading it down and holding other senior leaders to account.”

This is particularly important if the mentors you are trying to recruit are very senior. Leaders are able to set a precedent around mentoring so that it comes to be expected of all senior managers. Factor this in during planning stages so you’re not trying to convince people once the program has already launched.

Top tip: Before trying to recruit mentors and mentees, run a promotional campaign aimed at the senior leaders and those with influence in the business. Make sure they are bought into the vision of mentoring, specifically in the context of your organisation, and you will notice higher uptake.

2. Articulate the value

An important part of promoting your mentoring program is articulating the value. Mentoring is a voluntary activity which takes place on the side of your day to day role, and so if you’re asking people to give up their time, you need to be able to explain what’s in it for them. It will help to have clear and consistent messaging around mentoring so that everyone has the same idea of what it is and why they should care.

We’ll cover what the actual value is next, but firstly you need to understand how you are going to reach the mentors and mentees you are trying to recruit. Some ways could be:

  • Newsletters
  • Intranet notifications
  • Videos hosted on an internal system
  • Slack channel (or similar) for mentoring
  • A talk or event about mentoring
  • Via managers (team specific)
  • An internal blog or podcast
  • Reminders in email signatures / banners

You can use multi-channel promotion to successfully raise awareness and remind people about the program. Have a dedicated place for wider information that you can direct people to if they are interested in learning more, such as a PDF, a landing page, or a blog.


Involve your internal comms team at this stage to support you in reaching the right people, in the right way.

Now for the messaging itself…

3. Benefits for mentors

Recruiting mentors is notoriously challenging. One reason is the common misconception around who qualifies as a mentor (clue: it’s not only the most senior managers in your business) leaving many people feeling like they don’t have enough experience.

Another is the idea that ‘giving back’ is the only thing you gain from mentoring someone else. While that is a hugely rewarding benefit in itself, leaving people feeling like their job is more meaningful and reducing anxiety, there are also a host of career and leadership development benefits for mentors.

We’ve listed a number of benefits for mentors below to help you articulate the value for your mentoring program:

  • Increased self-confidence
  • Increased self-awareness
  • Leadership skill development
  • Strong communication skills
  • Art of delivering feedback
  • Art of asking questions
  • Becoming a good listener
  • Exposure to new and different perspectives
  • Growing a personal network
  • Increased chance of promotion
  • Increased job satisfaction
  • Supporting another person
  • Paying it forward
  • Learning from someone else

Depending on your program and who is involved, some of these benefits might be more key to your messaging than others. For example, with a Diversity & Inclusion programme discussing race or LGBTQ issues in the workplace, you would highlight ‘exposure to new perspectives’ and ‘self awareness’. Whereas a leadership mentoring program might be more linked to promotion rates and paying it forward. Choose your messaging carefully to increase interest.

Top tip: Where possible, speak with previous or existing mentors about the personal benefits they’ve experienced to help you articulate the value directly.

4. Benefits for mentees

The benefits for mentees are more widely acknowledged, but that’s not to assume that everyone will be aware of them, particularly if you are new to mentoring. There might also be some educating to be done here around what is expected of a mentoring relationship in case people feel intimidated or uneasy about what would be required of them.

The real value of mentoring is often not fully understood until you have personally experienced it, so make sure you articulate the benefits available to mentees, such as:

  • Increased self-confidence
  • Increased self-awareness
  • Develop strong communication skills
  • Growing a personal network within the business
  • Exposure to new and different perspectives
  • Learn to self-reflect
  • Improve goal-setting
  • Learn from other’s experiences
  • Learn to ask good questions
  • Being supported by someone
  • Being advocated for
  • Increased chance of promotion
  • Increased job satisfaction

Similarly, your messaging will vary depending on the participants and objective of the program. For example, growing a personal network will be a big driver for a new joiner or graduate program, whereas being advocated for would be more valuable for a program supporting under-represented or minority employee career development.

Top tip: As above, try and collect testimonials from mentees who’ve had positive experiences with mentoring.

On that note…

5. Share success stories

Messages resonate most when we can relate to the people telling them. Based on the tips above, ask around and find success stories from within your organisation that can help you promote the program.

Personal stories have the most impact, such as someone getting a promotion, overcoming a fear of public speaking, or hitting a career milestone. Ultimately, mentoring is about people, and so the more people you can involve in articulating the value, the easier recruitment will be – of both stakeholders, mentors and mentees.

Video has the biggest impact here, so approach individuals and ask if they’d be happy to share their story with you on film.

Top tip: During the program, if anyone has particularly positive feedback or anecdotes, ask them if they’re happy to film or at least write it down. That way, when it comes to recruitment of future programmes, you already have great content you can use.

6. Run a launch event

To create a buzz around the program, schedule a kick-off event and invite all key stakeholders and potential participants. Event invites act as another comms channel, and you can use this time to articulate the vision and value of the program face to face with your participants.

At Guider, we support our partners in this area by running onboarding webinars for mentors and mentees, covering benefits, best practice, and how to get the most out of the platform. We find this helps to provide an official start to the program, and catch any questions or concerns before attentions drift.

Top tip: Don’t stop at a launch event, but schedule in a mid-way point and wrap up event too. This will help create a sense of community around the program, maintain momentum, and provide a platform to celebrate success. For tips on effectively starting out, you should check out this article on starting mentoring programs.

Still struggling?

If you’ve tried all of the above and are still struggling to recruit mentors and mentees to your mentoring program, it could be worth revisiting the design phase to make sure there is no misalignment between what you’re trying to do and what you’re offering.

It’s essential that the people you are aiming to support with the program are involved in the design stage, so that you end up building a program with that group in mind.

📖 We’ve put together a guide to doing just that! 📖

This is particularly crucial for any mentoring programs connected to Diversity & Inclusion initiatives.

At Guider we’re always happy to talk mentoring, book a chat with our mentoring guides. 

The Complete Mentoring Toolkit

Everything you need to create and scale an effective workplace mentoring programme. Includes: setup checklist, matching guide, expert advice, proving ROI and much more.

What's next?

Whenever you’re ready… here are 3 ways Guider can help you supercharge your L&D with mentoring:

See how much mentoring can save your business with our ROI calculator

We've crunched the numbers from all of our customers to work out the financial value of mentorship to businesses. It might be just what you need to get executive buy-in... Click here to calculate.

Build your own mentoring programme

If you're looking to build and launch a mentoring programme in your organisation, then our guide is the best place to start. Read now.

Get a no-obligation quote for Guider's mentoring software

We get it, you want to know the price. Book a 20-minute call with our team and get a custom pricing proposal for your organisation. If it doesn't work for you, there's zero obligation to buy. Book now.

You might enjoy…

Skills-Based Insights in Mentoring, Coaching and Skill Development

What are skills-based insights? Gain visibility of your programs using Guider mentoring software and learn how skills-based insights can lead to transformative, invaluable that drives growth and development in your business.

What is Skills-Based Matching? Definition, Purpose, Benefits

What is skills-based matching? Here we define how skills-based matching can ensure the higher accuracy in your mentoring initiatives, for deeper connections and lasting engagement.

Enterprise Mentoring and Coaching Cannot Scale Without AI

If mentoring and coaching could have scaled, it would have. Learn how Guider's bespoke AI and automation features are driving and scaling mentoring initiatives in enterprise organisations.

How To Create The Perfect Mentor Match Within Your Organisation

We know for every employee and organisation, the "perfect match" is different. We've simplified the mentor matching process for you, combining automation with personal choice to drive engagement and scalability.

The Importance of Allyship in Mentoring

Why is allyship so important in mentoring? In for minority groups or sectors with low female representation, allyship is essential to bridge the gap. We interviewed Kevin Dainty for his expert advice on facilitating allyship.

AI is not the (only) answer: unlock the power of your workforce with mentoring

Miss our talk at Learning Technologies 2024? Catch up here where you'll learn that AI is not the only answer, it won't solve all your problems, but it might solve a few...

Guider AI